Monday, October 10, 2011

chaos theory


My university calculus professor was a poet.  Actually, he was a mathematician, a poet, and a philosopher all rolled into one grandfatherly type of a man.  I used to stay after class, nearly every session, and talk to him about philosophy and poetry, it was the only liberal arts education this science-oriented student was getting at the time.  In every other aspect of my academics I was eye ball deep in equations and periodic tables but I could talk to him about a haiku or the presence (or absence) of free will for ages.

But this isn't really about Grandfather Jerry.  This is about math and philosophy.  Grandfather Jerry just happened to be the person who I heard from for the first time that mathematics and philosophy are not really all that different from each other.  As odd as it may sound one needs a mind capable of thinking in the abstract to be good with numbers as well as to be good at expounding upon the great questions of life.  Someone who can excel in mathematics can certainly find a home in philosophical studies as well.

One place where math and philosophy intersect is in a concept called Chaos Theory.  The briefest technical explanation of this theory is that an outcome of a system is highly sensitive to its initial conditions.   Or to clarify, a small change in the initial condition of a system can lead to dramatic changes to the system on a long-term, grand scale.  The briefest non-technical explanation of Chaos Theory is what happens at the beginning, no matter how seemingly insignificant, can and will have a large effect on the eventual outcome of a situation.  Most people know Chaos Theory as The Butterfly Effect.  You know, a butterfly flaps its wings in Africa and three weeks later and a continent away a hurricane is born.

In math, Chaos Theory is used to describe situations in which small miscalculations like those inherent in rounding numbers for computation lead to different outcomes.  One person rounds one way and another rounds the other and in complicated mathematical equations they will each get a hugely different outcome.  In philosophy, the theory plays out much in the same way but instead of a numerical figure you are looking at the progression of a life based on a few (or a hundred, or a thousand, or a million...I think you get my point) events that have shaped the course of said life.

Chaos Theory is what makes prediction nearly impossible.   There is no telling how minuscule variables will effect the overall outcome.  Numbers, life, whatever, there is no predicting.

I certainly could never have predicted that I would be here at thirty-two years old, married and the mother of two children; one dead and the other currently napping peacefully in her crib.

Looking back it is easy to see how circumstance or certain choices I've made have shaped my life to where I am now.  For instance, I can trace the origins of my marriage back to a fight that I had with my friend Natalie when we were only nineteen years old, five years before I even met Leif.  A million other little decisions during those five years made it so that when we did finally meet we were both single and, eventually, in the place in our lives where we were able to fall in love.

On a deeper level I can see how a myriad of seemingly innocuous events, decisions, and circumstances ultimately led to George's conception and death.  From the particular time Leif and I had sex; a moment earlier or later and who knows what sperm would have fertilized that egg.  Who knows, we may have conceived a completely different baby who had no health issues at all.  Or the moment I sat in a parking garage rescheduling the ultrasound that would eventually reveal George's rapid heart rate.  That appointment was originally scheduled a week earlier and for some reason I can no longer recall I made the decision to push it back seven days.  Maybe if I had kept that original appointment we would have caught the condition early enough that the medication would have saved his life.  On the other hand, maybe the appointment would have been a day or two before his heart sped up and it would not have been caught at all until I developed the Mirror Syndrome and became seriously ill.  Or simply, one day I could have walked into the OB's office only to have her tell me that our baby's heart had stopped.

But none of those things happened.  Instead Leif and I conceived George and I made the appointment when I did.  It all led to George dying, and, something I've just come to grips with, Clio's existence.  This, folks, has been a hard pill for me to swallow.  We waited to try and conceive the second time around because I could not come to terms with the idea that a subsequent child would only be alive because George was dead.  Originally we had planned on waiting six to nine months after our first child was born to try to conceive the next and so in my mind if we waited that amount of time after George died we would still be sticking to our plan.  I wanted to pretend that in some reality, somewhere, had different choices been made, I would have all my babies with me.  George and Clio.

In reality, though, Clio is currently sleeping peacefully in her crib because George is dead.  Had George lived I would have been ovulating on a different schedule, and even if I was ovulating on the same schedule chances are that Leif and I would not have had sex at the exact same time on the exact same day.  Things would have gone down a different path.  I never even would have known the possibility of her existence.

But that is all history, so to speak.  What happens next, the rest of Clio's story and my own, there is no predicting.  The other children I will have, the people we will meet and interact with, the person Clio will marry, the kids she will have...all of their lives different because one little baby boy's heart beat too fast.

It's all a crazy mind fuck.  It is all just a web of chance interactions. It is all just chaos.



17 comments:

  1. All intriguing. I think at some point, each of us women who lost our babies came to a point of contemplation on this very topic. I don't know that I delved in quite as deep, but now this all has me thinking more intently about my life and those innocuous circumstances that be.

    Thanks. Beautifully written as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This makes me think of the three fates in greek methology: pulling, sniping and changing strings. It is true every second of our lives has an affect on the next. It is almost surreal to realize that if we could go back and change things we would lose what we have gained in the meantime.
    Your writing has made me get a bit philosophical in my thoughts here, analyzing each moment since. It is still to early for me to think of what I would lose if things had gone differently, but I imagine that one day I will reflect back on this and remember what you have said.

    Your writing is amazing.

    ReplyDelete
  3. B- I agree I think after a loss as profound as that of a child it makes one, eventually, take a look at their life and contemplate how things could have been different.

    Paula- I've thought many times about the Fates as well. Your loss is still so very recent and raw. It took me many, many months -over a year maybe- before I could even think about anything good that could have come out of George's death. It is still hard to think of it in those terms but knowing that my daughter wouldn't exist is crazy to me.

    Thank you ladies for your comments.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Absolutely. It is a chaotic mind fuck in the simplest sense of the theory. I'm sorry that you- or any of us- knows it in this manner. It all seems random.. until it isn't.
    Love and light to you...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yes, beautifully written Bree. It does feel like a crazy mind fuck, especially for those of us who embrace this idea of chaos. My reality, my experiences, my mind, they all seem to be revealing the same thing. This is all just a random chance. Life is given, life is taken away.

    Sometimes I envy those folks out there who believe in a heaven, or in god, or in the idea that some being out there is looking out for them. Those people who don't believe in chaos theory. It seems like the journey of babyloss would have more hope in it if you believed in these things and ideas.

    But here I am, still painfully subscribing to this life being all there is and that my existence, our existence, appears to have evolved from chaos, from chance.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think along these lines all the time. Especially thinking that the two eggs that made Angus and Juliet in particular, would have never come to make children if she'd lived. They would have passed through my system and would have never ended up fertilised. It is a lot to get my head around, to think that they are only here because she is not. And I know that if I went back to hospital just 24 hours earlier, she would have lived, and I would have possibly had one or two other children since, but most certainly not Angus or Juliet. You are right, it is one huge random, crazy, chaotic mindfuck.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm no mathemetician, I can be philosophical sometimes, but I'm not a philosopher. But, this is certaily all mindfuckingly chaotic.
    Not the rainbow babies (for me). But the what if's of different decisions. If I could turn back the clock just a week or two and had an elective cesarean, Joseph would be here. No doubt about it. But, I didn't, and he's not. And there's a chaotic mindfuck right there.
    This was a great post to read and really got me thinking. Thankyou. Philosphical mindfuck on top of back to back yoga sessions tonight make for a very tired BLM. x

    ReplyDelete
  8. Awe yes...the shoulda coulda wouldas...I like the chart. You see I have felt very "animal" since Camille died. Not all young survive...but being a human, I guess I felt like we get to have more control. It is a false sense of control. I know I am not cursed, I know that it was not something I did or did not do. It is not Karma. It is random, chaotic, FUCKING RANDOM SHIT. That JUST HAPPENED to happen to me! and you and some other not so lucky human creatures. I do hope I can have a rainbow baby because at least I would have the "I wouldn't have YOU" moments, but I know none of us would trade the child we lost for the one we could gain. It all feels so twilight zone. I think sometimes about how I had no idea how much I would love being a mother. Sometimes I wish I would have had children when I was younger, but then I wouldn't have been and done all the things I did. AND I wouldn't have KAI, because that one time, that one egg, that one sperm = HIM. Such crazy chance. I look around at people walking and talking...just random nobodies to me. They are somebody elses crazy chance. It is amazing any of us are living at all. Our lives seem So fragile .

    ReplyDelete
  9. Josh- Yes, exactly. I've had those same thoughts myself. Sometimes I get so envious that others go through this with confidence that they will see their child again someday. I like the way you put it, believing in some grand purpose to loss doesn't make it easier but does provide more hope.

    Sally- If George had lived I would possibly have another child too, or at the very least be pregnant again. But it would not be Clio. It is so hard to stare at a living child, love them with everything you are made of and know that they only live because another child is dead. Sometimes I think, would I change it? I used to unhesitatingly say yes. Now, with my daughter next to me...no. I would not change it. Sometimes it feels like I'm choosing one child over the other even though I'm not really.

    Kate- A week or two...damn. That is such a small amount of time in the grand scheme of life yet it will forever be the most pivotal weeks of your life. I feel the same way about the week between the original doctor's appointment and the one that I had rescheduled.

    Renel- "I look around at people walking and talking...just random nobodies to me. They are somebody elses crazy chance. It is amazing any of us are living at all. Our lives seem So fragile " I think this too, frequently. Especially the part that it is amazing any of us are living at all.

    Thank you all for the thoughtful comments.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I like the sound of Grandfather Jerry. He reminds me of my undergraduate supervisor, who was a poet and a scientist with a strong dose of Father Christmas thrown in for good measure. I liked him very much indeed.

    I don't think that anyone who makes their living from statistical analysis has much love for chaos. Or perhaps that is, in fact, what keeps us in a job?! Because humans do not want to admit that our powers of prediction are so very crummy!

    Sometimes I think it is all random chaos. Sometimes I think that it all had to be this way , that the way things have occurred is, in fact, the only way in which they could ever occur? If that makes any sense whatsoever?

    Obviously J's existence is kind of independent of G's, being one of twins. I'm not sure about R's. Maybe we would not have had any more children had both our twins survived? And the odds of any one particular individual being here are so slim that it makes me feel panicky, when I think about not having J or R or G (despite the fact that she is no longer in existence) I find myself struggling for breath.

    Perhaps the babies that we lost do continue some kind of shadowy existence, impacting on the world even in their inverse, as Clio's and R's lives develop and change. They are only here because their older brother and sister are not?

    ReplyDelete
  11. Catherine- "Perhaps the babies that we lost do continue some kind of shadowy existence, impacting on the world even in their inverse" This is the hope that I hold on to.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I am thinking about this all the time right now. It seems to suck the significance out of any individual life. Not that I ever really believed in much else, but still I never knew it felt this hard to face it.

    - Kari

    ReplyDelete
  13. Kari- Yes, it can be hard to face one's own significance. I know in light of G's death I see life as a much more random event. I haven't believed in any One guiding my existence for many years but I did always believe that I had some control myself. Now, not so much.
    I think, however, that I am just now beginning to understand how much an individual person can change the course of the lives of so many people. I guess it helps me to think that maybe G's death has impacted the lives of many others in ways I'll never know about. That he mattered, even if no one else knows it.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Oh, and P.S. Kari- It was our conversation the other week at Peekaboo that got me really thinking about all this stuff. I mean, I've thought about life in terms of chaos theory for quite awhile but I'd never sat down and given it as much thought in relation to George and Clio as I did after our conversation.

    ReplyDelete
  15. God that is such a beautiful thought..."that he mattered, even if no one else knows it." You've mentioned this before, about how he changed the world for the better, and how that is something you wanted to teach all your children. But the idea really hit home for me in light of this post.

    Loved our talk that day. So good to be with you.
    - Kari

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi, wondering around late at night at glow. 5 years since baby taz was born and died. Thanks for the Chaos Theory. Right away I had a similar but in some ways reversed reality-I felt how our lives into the future were changed the trajectory seriously skewed or f---ked. Because of baby taz we have Lucia-wow couldn't imagine not having her and the world not having her. Thanks for you words. i love Bukowski. In particular the candlelion poem.

    Lara

    ReplyDelete
  17. I. love. this. post. LOVE it. You expressed what I believe so much more beautifully than I ever could. Thank you.

    No matter what joys I may experience in the future, I will always long for Molly to be here, alive and well. And my heart will remain perplexed at the conundrum.

    This cause and effect *is* a bitter pill to swallow, and I so wish you could have both of your babies with you.

    ReplyDelete